Silencing Kramer: Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the music of Lady Gaga

R. Rudolf Ronyak
Department of Music, Portland State University

1. Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory and the art concept of expression

"History is a white European construct," writes Bloom. Where can we go from here? However, as an example, Bloom uses the term "ecomusicological pre-romantic theory" to denote the stasis of post-cultural music. Where capitalist hierarchies reinforce outmoded, inflexible language, diverse actors, on the other hand, challenge language and flourish in enriching Global language, advancing Brettist musical closet. Ergo, the observer is manifested into a inter-"scientific" minimalism that encompasses physicality within a paradox.

"We must transgress society before we envoice society." So argued Abbate at the beginning of "Unsung Voices". On one point, Brett was right: An abundance of self-analysises concerning modernist textual theory persist, and each of which might be espoused individually. My investigations relating to the role of the musicologist as improviser uncovered that a statement like "analysis comes from notated music" cannot exist (not to be confused with meta-"scientific" nationalism). It could be said that the tonality/atonality distinction prevalent in Brett's "Decomposition: Post-Disciplinary Performance" is also evident in "Deep Listening". Slim[1] holds that we have to decide between ecomusicological pre-romantic theory and the art concept of expression. The premise of inter-"scientific" minimalism implies that the purpose of the critic-listener is progression.

"Politics is performance vis-a-vis scholarship," stresses Marx; by contrast, according to Lady Gaga[2] , it is not so much politics that is performance vis-a-vis scholarship, but instead the modulation, and ergo, the pigeonholing, of politics. But Bloom promotes the use of the all-too-"structural" ideal of performance to problematize the musicologist. But can Rorem conclude, or one can insist restate, ecomusicological pre-romantic theory? The reply is absurd. Academe's deconstructing of culture, and insistence on instating the culture, enforces the art concept of expression. In a larger sense, e.g., Bloom uses the term "ecomusicological pre-romantic theory" to denote the transition between memory and music.

Thus the futility, or as some might say surrealist, romantic pigeonholing, can be observed, paradoxically, in mm. 141-142 of Shaw's String Quartets, although in a more redundant sense in measures 155-162, 204-230, and inverted in 259-268. The principal theme of the works of Cage is sub-, proto-, and post-narrative. (The subject is manifested into a inter-"scientific" minimalism that includes truth as a paradox.)

In a sense, in "A Year from Monday," Cage condemns ecomusicological pre-romantic theory; in "Notations", he problematizes his opinion, instead turning an ear to nobility pretense. When would, and even should, the canon, trapped by the "clandestine" super-serial narrative, decouple popular music, itself surprisingly defined by the semiotic proto-prolongation? My personal auto-ethnographical thoughts about inter-"scientific" minimalism suggest a scholarship of identity in the Adornoian-appropriationist vein. Several canons relating to a self-justifying entity exist.

The analyst/composer has a choice: either accept Heidegger's analysis of the art concept of expression or accept McClary's model of the art concept of expression and consequently reject that expression must come from our worth-system. Although modes of exclusions aim to respell neoliberal art, the contributions of gay studies problematize art and foreground diverse art, bolstering the disabled. In a larger sense, Randel[3] holds that we have to choose between ecomusicological pre-romantic theory and de-romantic composition. (Cusick promotes the use of inter-"scientific" minimalism to read through elitism.) However, Kramer's critique of queer musicology suggests that the significance of the performer is mere masturbation.

In a sense, my prior own discoveries concerning cultural post-romanticism found that a statement like "the concert hall is fundamentally a human construction" cannot exist--not to say we shouldn't suppress those who do. For instance, Cusick uses the term "the art concept of expression" to denote the role of the musician per se as (ethno-)musicologist. The participant has a choice: (a) accept Aristotle's essay on inter-"scientific" minimalism, or, somewhat usefully, (b) accept Cohn's monograph on inter-"scientific" minimalism. But the main focus of Hamilton's[4] analysis of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory is the dialectic, and eventually the economy, of rationalism qua rationalist disability. But why would inter-"scientific" minimalism "marginalize", we can insist challenge, sexism, conversely obviously hampered by a structural trans-Marxist sexualist concepts of narrative?

2. Koestenbaum resituated

Though Wagner famously stated, "society is problematic," the subtle ideas of Wright[5] show that in a way, society is not problematic, but it is the failure, and eventually the defining characteristic, of society that is problematic. Composition's transposing of sexuality espouses inter-"scientific" minimalism. Nevertheless when must music--imperceptably constrained by the cultural art concept of expression--reinforce the artist? This genius emerges again in mm. 91-97 of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, though tangentally, and yet stronger throughout bars 72-98, 259-270, and inverted in 33-55. "Tristan" examines East while Cusick's "On a Lesbian Relationship with Music" indexes West. It could be said that the individual is contextualized into a inter-"scientific" minimalism that subsumes history under a totality.

Though neoliberal, fixed homophobias entrench canonical ambiguity, ethnomusicological approaches problematize ambiguity and thrive in sustaining experimental ambiguity, envoicing ecomusicological pre-romantic theory. (Wissner[6]) In a sense, any number of theories about open work cannot be discovered, each of which Owens reframes separately [7]. (My investigations concerning the art concept of expression suggest a sociology of deprivileging in the McClaryian-narrativeist mode (not to be confused with romantic nationalism).)

Solie suggests the use of the art concept of expression to attack hierarchy. However, Dorf[8] states that we have to pick between neo-bimusicalist ambiguity and inter-"scientific" minimalism. Hence the primary idea of Stone's[9] critique of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory is a modernist worth system. Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory implies that music, perhaps ironically, has intrinsic meaning, given that the premise of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory is invalid. For whom might, some could say would, the art concept of expression, seeking only to escape quasi"scientific" experimentalist performance, marginalize and even privilege, or one should write prolong, the orchestra? The response for Boulez proceeds as follows:

3. Ueno and ecomusicological pre-romantic theory

If one investigates inter-"scientific" minimalism, one is confronted by a dilemma: either accept the art concept of expression or conclude that musical form is capable of artistic comment. The idea has precedent: The listener/critic has a paradox: (a) accept Plato's essay on inter-"scientific" minimalism, or, on the contrary, (b) accept Cusick's monograph on inter-"scientific" minimalism and subsequently reject that physicality serves to reinforce white, male, heterosexual perceptions of disability vis-a-vis politics. A number of constructions relating to both narrative and super-narrative cannot exist, and each might be analysed in turn. Straus promotes the use of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory to read and modify society. Therefore as an example, Straus uses the term "the textual concept(s) of listening" to denote the difference between music and performance. In a larger sense, the example of the art concept of expression intrinsic to Ueno's "Entropy of Cigarette Butts Across the Universe" is also evident in "...blood blossoms..." (contra Varwig [10]).

The Haupttema of the works of Saariaho is a redundant whole. This form, or rather obligation, can be observed in mm. 226-232 of Crawford's Diaphonic Suite, to a capitalist mindset throughout mm. 183-186 and (in retrograde) in 94-111. Musicology's deconstructing of culture, and insistence rather on decoupling the society depicted in culture, reiterates inter-"scientific" minimalism. Thus the thesis characterizing Allen's[11] model of meta-deconstructionist minimalism is the role of the musicologist as observer-analyst. But my auto-ethnographical publications relating to ecomusicological pre-romantic theory found that a statement like "history is capable of truth" cannot exist (the Abbateist overtones of the belief are unmistakable).

"Music is part of the newness of truth," says Marx. If ecomusicological pre-romantic theory is false, we have to decide between the art concept of expression and inter-"scientific" minimalism. However, the subject is manifested into a Bloomist anxiety of influence that merges memory with a entity. (In the places where globalizations seek to respell static art, the contributions of multicultural thinkers, subversively, rehear art and promote liberal art, amplifying popular culture.) The artist has a choice: one can accept Tovey's critique of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory or one can reject Attinello's essay on ecomusicological pre-romantic theory and subsequently accept that the goal of the performer is progression. Yet would inter-"scientific" minimalism, somewhat defined by the post-cultural Schenkerianist strategic dislocation, contextualize, even obscure, the art concept of expression (itself perhaps surprisingly standing up to a pre-textual improvisation)?

Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory suggests that sexuality, somewhat usefully, has real worth. It could be said that Brett suggests the use of inter-"scientific" minimalism to attack the critic. The characteristic theme of the works of Saariaho is both composition and all-too-composition. In a sense, if the art concept of expression is true, the works of Saariaho are an example of self-referential serialism.

E.g., Brett uses the term "de-romantic neoliberist theory" to denote a redundant whole. (The modulation quotes measures 60-84 of Cage's Empty Words, although in a more sonorous sense in bars 23-31 and 269-270.) Ergo, many self-compositions about inter-"scientific" minimalism may be revealed.

The subject is situated into a ecomusicological pre-romantic theory that includes physicality as a entity. Therefore music's increasing of politics enforces, and indeed affirms, the art concept of expression. My personal thoughts concerning inter-"scientific" minimalism promote a musicology of deprivileging in the Solomonian-theoryist vein (the Nietzscheist influences of the outburst are obvious). However, though cis-normative canons entrench Western composition, subcultures challenge composition and overcome by empowering World composition, advancing sub-modernist ambiguity.

Goodman[12] states that we have to choose between the art concept of expression and ecomusicological pre-romantic theory. In "Listen to This," Ross indexes ecomusicological pre-romantic theory; in "The Rest is Noise", by contrast, he denies inter-"scientific" minimalism. Why can Fuller analyse the musicologist? (The composer has a choice: (a) reject Barraque's monograph on the art concept of expression, or, alternatively, (b) accept Heidegger's model of the art concept of expression and consequently be complicit in that composition is a product of the musickers, but only if musical form is interchangeable with ambiguity; otherwise, one can assume that society is language.) In a larger sense, Adorno suggests the use of the art concept of expression to read society. Straus's analysis of the art concept of expression holds that scholarship is used to distort LGBTQ persons, but only if disability is in binary opposition to performance vis-a-vis truth; if that is not the case, one can assume that the significance of the composer per se is prolongation. The Haupttema of Rodin's[13] critique of inter-"scientific" minimalism is the economy, and some would say the absurdity, of "scientific" society.

4. Ecomusicologicalist rationalism and open form

In the works of Ross, an important concept is the conception of post-exotic sexuality. It could be said that the stasis, or instead paradigm, can be felt, ironically, in measures 202-208 of Beach's Piano Quintet, though in a cultural mode in mm. 165-184, 43-52, and hinted at in 218-244 (and, earlier, perhaps surprisingly throughout a few works of Handel). Cheng promotes the use of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory to problematize the status quo. The object is restated into a open form that encompasses physicality within a entity. But how must, and/or one should assert might, Timberlake (a bit hampered by proto-clandestine narrative) conflate, or better situate, the participant, similarly a bit hampered by proto-clandestine narrative?

"Music is a (white) European construct," emphasizes Solie; however, according to Mosley[14] , it is not so much music that is a (white) European construct, but rather the pigeonholing, and subsequent genius, of music. This idea has precedent: (McClary uses the term "inter-"scientific" minimalism" to denote the difference between culture and history.) An abundance of hermeneuticisms about the role of the listener/(ethno-)musicologist as critic are uncovered, every one Katz contrasts individually [15]. (My previous auto-ethnographical publications relating to neither ambiguity, nor trans-ambiguity, but rather pre-ambiguity found that a statement like "the Conservatory is capable of clear depiction" cannot exist.)

"We must rehear society before we can begin to reinforce society." So posited Born (echoing Derrida) in concluding "Music, Sound and Space" (distinct from Schenkerianist post-romanticism). Thus the futility of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory prevalent in Ross's "Rest is Noise" emerges yet stronger in "Einstein on the Beach", given the context. The concert hall's deconstructing of music, and insistence instead on silencing the music, reenacts "conceptual" inter-ambiguous theory. In a sense, although elitisms try to entrench male art, the contributions of women's rights read past art and uphold postmodern art, bolstering women. But Clemmens[16] states that we have to choose between open form and "scientific" canon. Marx promotes the use of inter-"scientific" minimalism to modify and read politics.

The principal focus of the works of Radiohead is the dialectic, and ergo, the newness, of cultural music. However, Born's essay on encompassment suggests that musical form, perhaps subversively, has undertones of intrinsic meaning. The musicologist has a dilemma: (a) reject Burney's analysis of the sexual concept of performance, or, on the other hand, (b) accept Riemann's critique of the sexual concept of performance and rightly reject that the stage is intrinsically used in the service of homophobia. The defining characteristic, or as some might say romanticist absurdity, can be heard in bars 38-61 of Reich's Music as Gradual Process (in the background) in mm. 156-166 and 213-221. Nevertheless why could ecomusicological pre-romantic theory reinforce the Other? The response for Ta-Nehisi Coates proceeds as follows:

(Society's voicing of society analyses open form.) Hence for instance, Marx uses the term "listener flattening" to denote the bridge between music and ambiguity vis-a-vis composition. It could be said that "Kid A" condemns triads where "Kid A" reframes dyads. Several self-prolongations concerning ecomusicological pre-romantic theory cannot be revealed, and each will be examined separately.

The idea of Linklater's[17] model of open form is the role of the artist as observer. But can inter-"scientific" minimalism--seeking only to escape the quasi"sonorous" theory--enrich, even consign, society? However, my discoveries concerning open form suggest a discipline of remorse in the Solomonian-theorizingist vein (in contrast to Brettist phallic economy).

(If analytical so-called Marxist theory be false, we have to pick between ecomusicological pre-romantic theory and inter-"scientific" minimalism.) The listener-musician is decoupled into a ecomusicological pre-romantic theory that subsumes scholarship under a whole. Ergo, music's analyzing of disability, and insistence instead on contextualizing the society prevalent in disability, espouses open form. My unpublished auto-ethnographical investigations about a self-supporting worth system discovered that a statement like "narrative is created by our worth-system" cannot exist (the Wagnerist overtones of the belief are absurd).

In a larger sense, Bloom promotes the use of "triadic" composition to challenge outdated, capitalist perceptions of performance. Though white, male, heterosexual modes of exclusions respell art language, diverse actors attack language and surmount by foregrounding popular language, empowering open form. Straus's monograph on ecomusicological pre-romantic theory implies that the purpose of the composer is mere masturbation. In a sense, the analyst has a choice: one can accept Heidegger's essay on inter-"scientific" minimalism or, on the contrary, one can reject Monk's monograph on inter-"scientific" minimalism and reflexively be complicit in that physicality may be used to negate otherwise ambiguous the bystander, given that dialectic is invalid.

Webster[18] holds that the works of Beethoven are empowering. Hence this obligation, or instead stasis, emerges yet stronger in measures 39-49 of Shaw's Partita (taking its surroundings into account) throughout mm. 105-135 and paraphrased in 31-48. But an abundance of compositions about the common ground between music and truth persist. It could be said that Adorno uses the term "structuralist proto-construction" to denote not, in fact, theory, but meta-theory. But for whom would ethnomusicology (completely standing up to a post-"scientific" postmodernist narrative) read around open form, itself somewhat surprisingly fleeing the all-too-textual ecomusicological pre-romantic theory?

5. Listenings of genius

When the performer confronts open form, she/he is struck by a paradox: either accept the romantic conception of context or decide that society has real worth. But what does this really mean? (The primary theme of the works of Beethoven is the sensitivity of de-feminine society.) Rivera[19] suggests that we have to choose between inter-"scientific" minimalism and open form. The subject is manifested into a inter-"scientific" minimalism that includes culture as a paradox.

Marx promotes the use of open form to modify sexuality vis-a-vis art. Although sexisms try to reinforce straight politics, the contributions of interdisciplinary scholars problematize politics and sustain queer politics, promoting the disabled. (Clark[20]) In a sense, the premise of ecomusicological pre-romantic theory states that academe is capable of intentionality. (Musicology's decoding of musical form affirms material nationalism.)

However, my discoveries relating to inter-"scientific" minimalism suggest a linguistics of difference in the Derridaian-performanceist style. "Last Jedi" enforces popular withoutness in the places where "Schindler's List" reiterates art withinness. The participant has a choice: (a) accept Born's analysis of Chengist musicology of caring, or, perhaps ironically, (b) accept Solie's essay on Chengist musicology of caring. Ergo, the modulation, or as some might say "modern", hermeneuticist collapse, can be heard in measures 227-228 of Ueno's On a Sufficient Condition for the Existence of Most Specific Hypothesis, albeit in a more surrealist sense throughout bars 180-210 and 71-78, and in many oeuvre of Haydn.

In sum, it is clear that the relationships among inter-"scientific" minimalism, ecomusicological pre-romantic theory, and open form, to say nothing of Ecoist open work, which will be the topic of our upcoming book, are moving in the direction of a modernist end. More examination of Williams's works, especially Star Wars, in the context of Abbateist voicelessness and the critic/(ethno-)musicologist's post-cultural self-conceptualism will be the bridge to progression.


1. Slim, A. N. B. (1978) Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory in the music of Cage. Tufts University Press

2. Lady Gaga, Seda ed./trans. (2000) Inter-"scientific" minimalism, Cage, and minimalism. Indiana University Press

3. Randel, P. S. (1984) Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the music of Williams. University of Michigan Press

4. Hamilton, Hans ed. (2003) Atonality/Atonality: Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory in the works of Wagner. Edward Mellyn Press

5. Wright, A. (1984) Inter-"scientific" minimalism after Boulez. Wesleyan University Press

6. Wissner, Reinhold (2015) Inter-"scientific" minimalism against ecomusicological pre-romantic theory. University of Illinois Press

7. Owens, R. (1895) Language, scholarship, and composition: Minimalism, inter-"scientific" minimalism, and dominant "hermeneutic" theory. Edward Mellyn Press

8. Dorf, Andreas ed./trans. (1927) The Forbidden Window: Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the writings of Tomlinson. McGraw Hill

9. Stone, F. (2001) Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the music of Ueno. Princeton University Press

10. Varwig, Jane ed. (1980) The Analysis of Sensitivity: Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory in the music of Saariaho. Harvard University Press

11. Allen, I. (1969) Collapse the Context: Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the music of Muhly. Scarecrow Press

12. Goodman, John ed./trans. (1998) Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the works of Ross. W.W. Norton

13. Rodin, Y. W. K. (2010) Instating Wagner: Inter-"scientific" minimalism and ecomusicological pre-romantic theory. M.I.T. Press

14. Mosley, Martin (1871) Reinventing Urbanity: Inter-"scientific" minimalism and ecomusicological pre-romantic theory. Indiana University Press

15. Katz, E. ed./trans. (1983) Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the works of Ta-Nehisi Coates. University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill Press

16. Clemmens, Michael ed. (1997) The Failure of Memory: Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory in the works of Radiohead. Wesleyan University Press

17. Linklater, G. (1946) Beethoven, inter-"scientific" minimalism, and minimalism. University of Massachusetts, Amherst Press

18. Webster, Paul ed./trans. (2002) Compositions of Form: Inter-"scientific" minimalism after Feldman. W.W. Norton

19. Rivera, H. Z. (1888) Withinness/Withoutness: Ecomusicological pre-romantic theory without inter-"scientific" minimalism. Edward Mellyn Press

20. Clark, Rudolf ed. (1879) Inter-"scientific" minimalism in the works of Williams. Indiana University Press

Automatic bad new musicology paper generator: based on the Postmodernist essay generator and the Dada engine.

 

In the further interest of self-parody, I am starting work on an Old Musicology random essay generator; please email me with ideas. All I know is that every paper will begin "On f. 3v, a new watermark ..." etc.