Modernist proto-construction and trans-textual composition

Hans U. Pollock
Department of Sonic Studies, Brandeis University

1. Rorem and new musicology

When the critic per se confronts modernist proto-construction, she is faced with a dilemma: one can accept trans-textual composition or one can decide that disability has intrinsic meaning, given that Born's critique of encompassment is invalid. But what does this really imply? (Performance's manifesting of language, and insistence on analyzing the composition prevalent in language, reframes trans-textual composition.) In a larger sense, the defining characteristic can be felt in mm. 232-244 of Wagner's Tristan in mm. 220-244 and paraphrased in 286-312. Ergo, the individual is situated into a Abbateist narrativity that merges scholarship with a worth system. The observer has a choice: (a) accept A. B. Marx's monograph on Leitmotiv, or (b) reject Dell'Antonio's model of Leitmotiv and subsequently be complicit in that context is a product of our worth-system, but only if musical form is distinct from ambiguity; if that is not the case, one can assume that physicality is history.

When we grapple with modernist proto-construction, we are struck by a paradox: either accept trans-textual composition or, alternatively, conclude that performance is used to negate otherwise native diverse actors. But when might, some would say could, Mahler--a bit trapped by a "ecomusicological" "scientific" proto-prolongation--uphold the artist? The reply for Attinello proceeds as follows: Therefore though musicologists seek to entrench outdated, elitist memory, the contributions of ethnomusicological approaches problematize memory and prevail in empowering diverse memory, envoicing Leitmotiv. The object is restated into a trans-textual composition that includes truth as a entity. My unpublished discoveries about modernist proto-construction promote a politic of new perspectives in the McClaryian-theorizingist mode (not to be confused with so-called conceptualist nationalism qua nationalism). But an abundance of canons concerning not, in fact, theory, but sub-theory cannot exist, each of which Amati-Camperi denies individually [1]. Expression's disciplining of music indexes trans-textual composition.

"We must transgress society before we respell society." So wrote Straus (echoing Dubiel) in the preface of "the Crawford Seeger book". The principal idea of the works of Rorem is neither proto-appropriation, nor proto-proto-appropriation, but rather de-proto-appropriation. In a sense, Adorno promotes the use of trans-textual composition to analyse society. The form, or as some might say textual, cultural modulation, can be felt, perhaps paradoxically, in measures 236-240 of Rorem's Five Poems of Walt Whitman in bars 126-152 and hinted at in 45-53, and, earlier, in embryonic form in a few oeuvre of Debussy.

However, if inter-serialist self-composition be true, we have to choose between trans-textual composition and modernist proto-construction. (The serialism/"minimalism" distinction depicted in Rorem's "String Quartet No. 3" emerges again in "Five Poems of Walt Whitman".) Solie's critique of Leitmotiv states that art is capable of content, given that the premise of phallic economy is valid. Yet when might experimental capitalist theory transgress elitism, similarly a bit trapped by a "ecomusicological" "scientific" proto-prolongation? The answer is trivial.

In a larger sense, as an example, Brett uses the term "modernist proto-construction" to denote a meta-"scientific" paradox. The analyst has a choice: either reject Derrida's critique of Leitmotiv or accept Barraque's analysis of Leitmotiv. In a sense, a number of performances about trans-textual composition exist, and every one can be condemned individually. My personal investigations relating to clandestine narrative revealed that a statement like "the goal of the musicologist/composer is artistic comment" cannot exist--not to argue we shouldn't attempt it. It could be said that the individual is decoupled into a modernist proto-construction that merges sexuality with a entity.

In the places where outdated modes of exclusions reinforce uncritical politics, women's rights attack politics and advance ambiguous politics, sustaining the Other. Ethnomusicology's contextualizing of society, and insistence on hearing the culture vis-a-vis disability intrinsic to society, reiterates, or we might insist reframes, Leitmotiv. Thus a number of compositions about the role of the participant as performer per se are discovered. The Haupttema of Exner's[2] model of modernist proto-construction is the futility, and eventually the stasis, of textual scholarship. (The genius quotes measures 226-235 of Radiohead's Bends, given the context, and further throughout bars 165-167 and (in retrograde) in 155-158.)

Hence Solomon's critique of peacock-culture implies that society, subversively, has real worth. Nevertheless could "triadic" romantic theory, somewhat constrained by a super-rationalist performance, situate, even consign, academe? But if trans-textual composition is true, we have to decide between modernist proto-construction and Leitmotiv. In a larger sense, Kramer suggests the use of the insider conception of narrative to problematize and modify music. Bent[3] suggests that the works of Abbate are modernistic.

2. Abbate and disability musicology

When we examine trans-textual composition, we are faced with a dilemma: either accept modernist proto-construction or, on the other hand, decide that composition may be used to negate and even distort otherwise Global LGBTQ persons. The orchestra's decoding of musical form examines trans-textual composition. The listener has a choice: (a) reject Burney's essay on disability musicology and reflexively accept that composition must come from the musicians, or (b) accept Cheng's analysis of disability musicology. (Straus uses the term "trans-textual composition" to denote not theory, but quasitheory.)

The theme of the works of Abbate is the difference between language and physicality. But what does this really signify? But if modernist proto-construction is false, we have to choose between trans-textual composition and post-textual minimalism. Cusick's monograph on modernist proto-construction holds that the Conservatory is part of the paradigm of memory, but only if performance is roughly equivalent to ambiguity; if that is not the case, music comes from our worth-system. The subject is manifested into a trans-textual composition that subsumes truth under a totality. My own thoughts concerning modernist proto-construction promote a discipline of new perspectives in the Adornoian-ambiguityist style.

However, though globalizations attempt to respell archaic history, the contributions of interdisciplinary scholars, perhaps usefully, rehear history and thrive in foregrounding feminine history, enriching disability musicology. It could be said that this dialectic, or rather absurdity, is also evident in mm. 291-313 of Rorem's String Quartet No. 3 (taking its surroundings into account) throughout measures 74-93, 185-197, and 140-167 (and in the compositions of Mozart). For whom should "scientific" improvisation challenge, and/or indeed entrench, communism? The thesis of Wissner's[4] model of modernist proto-construction is the role of the composer-observer as critic. Solie promotes the use of trans-textual composition to read around the canon.

But any number of canons relating to disability musicology may be found, every one Shreffler analyses in turn [5]. (In "Nymphea," Saariaho enforces trans-textual composition; in "...a la fumee", by contrast, she affirms Marxist performance.) Ergo, the (ethno-)musicologist has a paradox: one can reject Plato's critique of modernist proto-construction and consequently accept that music has undertones of significance or one can reject Beethoven's essay on modernist proto-construction. In a sense, Fitzpatrick[6] implies that we have to pick between trans-textual composition and trans-textual composition.

As an example, Solie uses the term "all-too-cultural hermeneuticist theory" to denote pre-, post-, and sub-narrative. Listening's instating of music, and insistence instead on prolonging the music, reenacts trans-textual composition. My prior auto-ethnographical discoveries about a Schenkerian paradox found that a statement like "the stage is capable of intentionality" cannot exist (the Tickist notions of this belief are absurd).

In sum, it is obvious that the relationships among modernist proto-construction, trans-textual composition, and disability musicology (and also the "sonorous" concept(s) of analysis, which we have barely had space to touch upon) are moving in the direction of a bimusicalist goal. More study of Fuller's works, in particular The Pandora Guide to Women Composers, in the context of Wagnerist Gesamtkunstwerk and the musicker's romantic analysis will be the tool to prolongation.

1. Amati-Camperi, Stefano (1983) Economy the Analysis: Romanticism, the romantic concept(s) of listening, and modernist proto-construction. University of Chicago Press

2. Exner, H. (2011) Trans-textual composition in the works of Abbate. Indiana University Press

3. Bent, Drew (1990) Modernist proto-construction in the music of Zorn. Indiana University Press

4. Wissner, E. (1996) Culture, art, and society: Modernist proto-construction after Cusick. Wesleyan University Press

5. Shreffler, Drew ed./trans. (1887) Trans-textual composition in the music of Saariaho. Scarecrow Press

6. Fitzpatrick, J. W. P. ed. (2013) Foreground/Figure: Modernist proto-construction in the writings of Fuller. M.I.T. Press

Automatic bad new musicology paper generator: based on the Postmodernist essay generator and the Dada engine.


In the further interest of self-parody, I am starting work on an Old Musicology random essay generator; please email me with ideas. All I know is that every paper will begin "On f. 3v, a new watermark ..." etc.